https://youtu.be/731tXqFP0Mc?si=7raIPY_NFZhHut8B
I watched Void Burger slaughter Christophe Gans over the Silent Hill 2 movie. I'll be transparent. I somewhat enjoyed the Silent Hill 1 movie. Visually it had a lot going for it but the movie went off the rails the moment Christophe gave us an idiotic spew on how Harry acted more like a woman so that's why they replaced him with a mother named Rose. Gans justified this with the "Mother is the name for God on the lips of all children" quote. (He ripped that off from the original The Crow movie with Brandon Lee which I highly recommend!)
We shouldn't be surprised. He also missed the whole point of Alessa. As in she was not a little girl whom made a pact with a demon to get revenge. Rather the town cult wanted to use her psychic manifestation abilities to birth their God into existence thus bringing about paradise. Alessa herself no longer wanted to exist at all. In a last ditch effort for happiness she split off a part of her soul that could be happy by growing up as a normal little girl with loving parents.
The obvious points
1. The Order labeled itself as good. They didn't acknowledge they were evil. Believable villains usually don't have the self reflection necessary to see themselves as the bad guys. They perceive their drastic atrocious actions as being unfortunate yet necessary sacrifices for a greater cause. They were not blatantly worshiping demons. They were worshiping a twisted interpretation of Christianity. Even Valtiel is suppose to be an angel. (Despite his dark fey or demonic like appearance.)
2. Alessa didn't want revenge on the town. She wanted an end to her pain and suffering. The manifestations in the town are the after effect of her psychic powers spilling out and mixing with Silent Hill's latent supernatural energies that the Native Americans recognized hundreds of years ago.
3. Harry was the positive trope of the good father willing to do anything to save his child. Contrary to Gans's moronic point of view, many such men still exist. Dads are just as important to a child's development as moms are.
4. Upon my first viewing of the movie I was fine with Dahlia being a caring yet ideologically captured mother. To me it added more depth to a character whom was otherwise more cartoonishly evil than Cruella Deville from 101 Dalmations or Queen Bavmorda from Willow! I'll give Gans a pass on this. Classic Dahlia was a shallow version of the "evil old hag" trope in the original source material. The most interesting things about her were the gyromancy rituals and her Irish heritage. (Spin darling, spin! Fall down and do it all over again!)
I've drawn and written Silent Hill fan fic slop before. An unusual twist for me as I'm not big on doing fan related works. But I respect the original canon enough I wouldn't tarnish it by placing my own crude blasphemies onto a pedestal. If Konami contacted me to come up with my own Silent Hill I would either outright refuse the offer or try to convince them I wanted to do an original survival horror ip only loosely inspired by Silent Hill. Too many fake fans with big money want to control and change the things they claim to love. Not me. I recognize my own limitations, flaws, kinks, and weird quirks would taint the stew if I threw them into the cooking pot of what is already there.
"Silent Hill" also isn't the only horror series with these themes. Anybody played the F.E.A.R trilogy? Alone In The Dark The New Nightmare? Eternal Darkness? The Suffering 1 and 2? There are a lot of stories with corrupt authoritarians, cults, tormented kids with super powers, psychological symbolism, tragedy fueled curses, drug abuse, and supernatural mambo jumbo. This is why simply slapping the "Silent Hill" moniker onto any story with slight similarities is grifting hackery. I don't care what the retards at Konami said. Silent Hill is not a phenomenon that can happen anywhere. It's a place that has its' own distinct identity. You can make your "haunted town game" but it should strive to be its' own thing. Yes, a Silent Hill related incident can happen in another place. But if it does it needs to somehow tie into the preestabalished lore and some of the preestabalished characters. Otherwise it is "Silent Hill" only in name.
Pssst, Gans fucked up the premise behind Silent Hill 2 as well! Wow, what a shocker! Ironically I don't feel bad about this because at least the Silent Hill 2 game remake was not complete trash. It kind of balances out! Now I will attempt to discuss Void Burger's astute observations.
1. In the film adaptation James drives a mustang, smokes cigarettes, and is a wealthy artist. I wish I was cheekily taking you for a ride!
2. This Mary is not even James's terminally ill wife. She's just his side piece. Worse, she's apart of "The Cult" that does this icky ceremony where everyone does psychedelic drugs, licks her, and symbolically devours her. My hypothesis is Gans took some of Claudia's backstory, mixed it into Mary's, and threw in his own barely disguised sexual fetish!
3. Angela is now just another manifestation of Mary. What in the ever loving fuck? Angela was her own person with her own autonomy. She's traumatized because her father sexually abused her. She didn't know Mary nor is connected to Mary in any way.
4. Laura no longer looks or acts like an innocent child oblivious to what's going on in James's other world. She was remolded into the creepy exposition dumping ghost girl caricature whom has a grotesque living baby doll for the SHOCK FACTOR! (Guess Gans played RE 8 Village then copy pasted the dollhouse section!)
5. They did my boy Eddie so dirty I don't even want to talk about it. We don't get to see him slowly unravel. He's just there then gone. Or rather the violent hobo that stole Eddie's ID card is!
If you enjoyed this film you are a brain dead sheep. I can usually forgive someone for liking something that is cringe. I thought Resident Evil 6 was a total banger! (LOL!) But this film desecrates everything Silent Hill ever stood for. If Gans wanted to tell his own deviant sex cult horror story with a suave rich painter protagonist he should have made it an original film. But I guess that would have required integrity and actual balls!
For anyone not familiar with my Lol-Cow Silent Hill streak? I had a para-social crush on Alessa and Heather. I dug how Silent Hill 3 connected to Silent Hill 1. The past life resurrection shtick resonates with me and tickles my funny bone!
I concocted a love story between Walter Sullivan and Alessa Gillespie wherein two traumatized people saved each other from their own dark fates. (While potentially saving Claudia as well.) It was never meant to be in the same reality as canonical Silent Hill. In my adaptation The Order was an HOA run communist regime using thinly veiled religious propaganda to keep people complacent.
My idea for the alternate Silent Hill was an isolated Potemkin village social experiment built atop an underground laboratory with a particle collider contributing to all the paranormal anomalies. The people up top grew the food and manufactured the working parts for the machines that the scientists needed to continue their work below. There was a deliberate disparity of awareness wherein the staff working on the particle collider knew what was going on yet never divulged that info to the unknowing citizens apart of their research. The Home Owners Association cronies were the thugs and social manipulators compensated to protect the technocrats as they obfuscated the truth from the local population.
The Alessa in my universe was older and never digi-volved into Heather. The torn ill fitting private university garb of her younger years was meant to represent how much of a neglected outsider she was. The college itself was more of an indoctrination center than a place for learning so it insisted on a conformity based dress code. I will level with you. Maybe busty adult women wearing smaller sized puritan frock themed school uniforms is one of MY barely disguised sexual fetishes! Touche!
Anyway, she likewise had psychic powers that were the harbinger for a similar catastrophe when the particle collider began manifesting her overactive repressed imagination into reality. The Order have a boardroom meeting and decide to get their contract killer Walter to deal with the problem. In predictable fashion he begins doubting his superiors and after developing feelings for Alessa he can no longer go thru with the assassination contract.
Had Alessa been allowed to freely express herself and speak her mind without punishment, confinement, smug ridicule, and being forced to take questionable psychiatric medications her psychic abilities would not have raged out of control and reacted with the particle collider. Authoritarian regimes always create their own apocalypses regardless if their core beliefs sprouted forth from religion, fascism, or communism. I really wanted to drive that home. Hell is paved with good intentions hand in hand with evil actions. Speeches about progress always include rhetoric such as "You cannot make an omelet without breaking eggs!" or "We must surrender our privileges to serve the higher nobler goal!." You would think we would all learn pattern recognition from history's lessons but alas, there are always useful idiots just waiting to be tapped!
The distinction between me and Gans is I would be staunchly against my fan fiction becoming a published work for mass consumption and media literacy. (Unless I retitled it "Quiet Mountain" and further refined it into something completely original.)
For clarification, Warren and Wren really are my best friend's tabletop rpg characters. As I was drawing them I realized they had similar traits to Alessa and Walter so I indulged in those overtures. (I mixed in other inspirations as well because as an old fart I have a wealth of material in my memory vault!)
I leave it all up to interpretation. If you want to believe Alessa and Walter were past lives of Wren and Warren from a divergent time line split off from the original Silent Hill continuity be my guest. You can also chuck those particular details into the dumpster! (Hopefully along with Gans's Silent Hill adaptations!)